John Nephew


Maplewood City Council Policy & Politics

 



Friday, June 22, 2012

Resolution Against "Marriage Amendment"

Via Minnesotans United for All Families:
On Monday, June 11, the Maplewood City Council voted 3 to 2 to oppose the proposed marriage amendment in Minnesota. The resolution – originally brought forward by Council Member Llanas – said in part that the “proposed amendment would be would be contrary to the purpose of our State Constitution to protect the rights, privileges and freedom of conscience of all citizens” and urged Minnesotans to vote no in November.
Based on past votes and comments, I'm going to guess that Marv Koppen and Bob Cardinal were the anti-gay, anti-equality votes against this resolution.  But I'm very glad that the progressive majority that remains on the council did the right thing and spoke up for human rights and decency and against this bigoted and discriminatory ballot measure.

Labels:

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Bob Hill Breaks His Word

Last week I got a letter from Bob Hill of Mahtomedi -- the same Bob Hill who hosted this year's Independence Party caucuses at his home -- announcing that he will run in the DFL primary for House District 43A. He had sought endorsement from the local DFL party, but lost it to Peter Fischer. He also told the endorsing convention that he would abide by their decision.

Since he's announced his intent to break that promise, I wanted to take some time to explain why Bob Hill has persuaded me that he is not fit for office.

Soon after the convention, Mr. Hill sent an open letter to Peter Fischer, copying it to all of the HD43A delegates. In it, Mr. Hill warned that he "cannot in good conscience" stay out of the campaign due to various "concerns" and "grave doubts" that were brought to him by "various delegates." Reading his letter, I concluded that he was looking desperately for any rumor or misperception that could be twisted into an excuse to break his promise to respect the endorsement.

I wanted to highlight this particular passsage from Mr. Hill's early April letter, as it relates specifically to city council politics in Maplewood:

Third, several of the delegates have informed me that in 2011 you were the campaign manager to someone who “operates a non-union construction/re-modeling business.” In light of the “Right to Work” controversy that is now infecting our politics at the state capitol, how do you explain your support for a political candidate/elected official who refuses to become a “signatory” to the construction trades union agreement protecting living wage jobs in the construction industry? Perhaps most importantly---at least for people like me---how are you going to become a champion for unionized labor at the legislature when your political record as recently as 2011 indicates just the opposite to be the case?

In 2011, there were two council seats open. None of the candidates for those seats in the primary or general election was in the construction/remodeling business. Peter Fischer supported the two DFL-endorsed candidates (Marv Koppen and me), neither of whom is in the construction or remodeling business. Peter was not anyone's campaign manager that year. In terms of doing the most basic homework before climbing out on a limb of political attack, Mr. Hill fails miserably. (One wonders what he means by his claim to have "taken the time to painstakingly verify the information I have received" -- perhaps he doesn't know how to use Google?)

The attack that Mr. Hill is attempting to regurgitate is of course one that was leveled against Mayor Will Rossbach by the supporters of Rossbach's 2009 opponent, Diana Longrie. Had Mr. Hill actually looked into it, he might have learned that not only was Rossbach endorsed by the local DFL in 2009 (making it less than a surprise that the local DFL Senate District Chair -- Peter Fischer -- would be supporting him), he also was endorsed pretty much across the board by labor, including the Carpenters and the Building Trades.

He might also have learned that Rossbach earned labor's support time and again by his actions in office. Rossbach stood up for the labor rights of city employees, who suffered illegal retaliation for exercising those rights during Longrie's tenure as Mayor. Longrie's 2007 budget, which Rossbach opposed, demoted all of the city's department heads by creating new managerial positions above them. It actually stated, "This reorganization is required for accountable management of all city departments given the action by department heads to vote to form a labor bargaining group in October 2006." In other words, they were all demoted in retaliation for exercising their labor rights.

What's more, during those dark days of anti-labor forces controlling city hall, Peter Fischer was himself working to bring change. Besides speaking out in public against the anti-labor agenda of the Longrie regime, and supporting Will for re-election, Peter helped recruit me to run in 2007 and served as my campaign manager. With my election to the council, the balance of power changed and, among other things, we restored a healthy labor-management situation in city hall.

So in summary -- Mr. Hill claims to be gravely concerned that Peter Fischer, who at the time was chair of the local DFL, actively worked to get the DFL-endorsed, labor-endorsed candidate elected as Mayor of Maplewood. That doesn't make a lot of sense as Hill's justification of breaking his word and challenging the DFL-endorsed candidate, unless he's not really a supporter of the DFL or Labor.

To me, as someone involved in the Maplewood political scene for a few years, Hill's attacks on Fischer show that he has eagerly swallowed the kool-aid of the anti-DFL faction that has infiltrated our local DFL party. These are the folks who have been running their "operation chaos" in recent elections -- with Diana Longrie's primary challenges to Leon Lillie and Betty McCollum. As I noted in an entry back in February 2010, Longrie was still listed as an officer of the local Republican party unit when she filed to run as a Democrat against Lillie in 2008.

Speaking of which, while Mr. Hill describes himself as "a life-long Democrat" in that same April letter, according to the White Bear Press (1/31/12), "The nearest Independence Party caucuses are at the residenceof Bob Johnson-Hill, 450 Emerald Lane, Mahtomedi (contact:bob@roberthilllaw.com)..." It's a little odd for "a life-long Democrat" to be the contact person and host for another party's caucuses, isn't it?

I have no problem with people changing parties. Parties and individuals can change and evolve, and people should certainly seek out and work with those who share their political vision. But I think candidates should be forthcoming about how and why they changed, if they are seeking a party's endorsement. Mr. Hill provided no such explanation, as far as I know -- he presented himself as "a life-long Democrat," repeatedly invoking the memory of Paul Wellstone and well-known Wellstone slogans. For someone who caucused with a different party until he found himself in a newly drawn DFL-leaning legislative district without an incumbent, this now seems deeply cynical and deceptive.

The bogus attacks on Fischer, which boil down to "you're not a real DFLer," are all the more disingenuous in light of Hill's own chameleon history.

And just for a cherry on top: While we were fighting for labor rights on the ground in Maplewood in 2007, Bob Hill, running for Congress at the same time, was quoted saying, "I'm not beholden to teachers' unions, the AFL-CIO or other unions" (per MN Campaign Report, 7/31/07). In other words, when wooing the voters of the conservative 6th District, he went out of his way to distance himself from organized labor. Now he's in a district that is more labor friendly, and he's concerned that we need a "champion for unionized labor" in the legislature.

Given all this, I don't know what Bob Hill's true political views are, or if he even has any. I do know that I don't trust him, and I certainly won't be voting for him.

Labels:

Wednesday, May 09, 2012

Cardinal Responds

In a Letter to the Editor in the Pioneer Press, Bob Cardinal responds to the media coverage resulting from his forwarding pictures of naked women and anti-Muslim text to a Pioneer Press reporter. Perhaps he was concerned that people would forget the incident?

His summary paragraph:
Facts: This email was passed on to me. I passed it on to Sarah Horner. Reporter shared email with fellow reporter and the editor and did not delete. Bob Cardinal is defamed by St. Paul Pioneer Press. Additional result: An inhumane circus-media-debasement of our culture. The St. Paul Pioneer Press should never have printed this article. Two wrongs do not make a right.
I guess "blame the media" never goes out of style for some politicians.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, May 01, 2012

Fox 9 On the Story

I came across this embedded video story on a website called "Islamaphobia Today."

Don't miss the reporters' banter afterward, as they boggle over just what the heck Cardinal was trying to say. ("Patent on Fraud"? Did he really say he has a "patent on fraud"?)

Labels: , ,

Monday, April 30, 2012

Good Grief

If you believe him, Bob Cardinal thinks the appropriate way to express his shock at an offensive sexist, anti-Muslim e-mail with attached pictures of naked women, is to forward it without comment to everyone in his address book -- including Pioneer Press reporter Sarah Horner.

It would seem that the judgment of "negligent and ill-advised" isn't limited to Mr. Cardinal's campaign practices...

Labels: , ,

Thursday, December 15, 2011

Cardinal's Fine in the Review

This week's Maplewood Review includes an article about the fine levied against incoming councilmember Bob Cardinal for soliciting an illegal corporate campaign contribution in the course of his campaign this fall.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, December 06, 2011

3-Judge Panel Rules Against Cardinal, Highland

Last Wednesday, November 30th, was the evidentiary hearing for my campaign complaint complaint against Bob Cardinal and Highland Sanitation, alleging an illegal corporate campaign contribution. Today I received the court's decision in the mail. I've scanned the judges ruling and uploaded it as a PDF.

The three-judge panel concluded that Highland did violate the law (211B.15 subd. 2) by making a prohibited corporate campaign contribution to Mr. Cardinal, and that Mr. Cardinal violated the law (211B.15 subd. 13 and 211B.13 subd. 2) by knowingly soliciting a prohibited corporate campaign contribution.

At the hearing I requested that the judges be lenient towards Highland, because it seemed clear to me that they had been unaware of the law and had stopped as soon as they were informed, by way of my campaign complaint, that what they were doing was illegal. In contrast, I suggested that Mr. Cardinal should be penalized more harshly, as an experienced candidate who had been given the rules and had an obligation to understand the election laws applying to his many campaigns for city office. I am pleased that the judges appear to have agreed, in imposing a nominal $100 penalty on Highland but five times as large a fine on Mr. Cardinal for his "negligent and ill-advised" actions.

Labels: , ,

Monday, November 28, 2011

Perspective

Tonight the city council will vote on whether or not to adopt the organized hauling plan that has been developed over a process that, it's fair to say, has been going on at least since last summer.

The out-of-town hauler group, which is probably more concerned about what might happen on their turf in Roseville, sent another big mailing to residents to drum up opposition.  However, with the city actually having specifics of a plan to share with people, I've noticed a much higher proportion of e-mails and phone messages in favor of the organization plan than was the case in the past.

Still, people are skeptical -- they've learned not to trust haulers, and so they sometimes don't believe the numbers the city has obtained through this process.  One person who wrote assumed that the city postcard's rates must be talking about cost per week, not cost per month for weekly service.  He could not believe that he would see a 60% savings.  It's ironic that peoples' distrust of haulers' rate quotes, based on bad experiences, has led many to trust a group of haulers (defending their profits) over their city government (trying to save them millions over the next few years).

Meanwhile, today's mail brought me a copy of Little Canada's city newsletter -- something we often get, due to being in the 55117 ZIP code.  It mentions that they received the results of a scientific survey of their residents about satisfaction with various city services.  Among the very highest-rated: their organized refuse & recycling program, which 96% of Little Canada residents rate as "excellent" or "good."  I've heard that White Bear Lake found similar results in their own similar survey in the past year.

Many people are afraid of change, and I suspect that they have a particular cynicism about trash because of experiences dealing with many haulers.  But if Maplewood passes this plan, I expect that it will reach the same level of popularity as organized systems have in our neighbor cities -- and when the contract expires, no serious candidate for city office will campaign on a platform of going back to an open system (just as candidates opposing organized trash this year were not willing to voice any complaints about organized recycling).  After people see the benefits, it's going to be tough to run on a promise of doubling everyone's rates in order for them to enjoy "choice" and the privilege of having half a dozen or more trucks drive down their street on trash day in place of one.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Resolution Opposing Stadium Sales Tax

One of the agenda items at last night's city council meeting was a resolution regarding the proposed Ramsey County sales tax for funding a Vikings stadium on the Twin Cities Army Ammunition Plant site in Arden Hills.

At our previous council meeting, I had a council presentation on the topic of the stadium and the Stillwater Bridge, as examples of two issues that were not matters over which the council had any control, but which had significant impact on the residents and businesses of Maplewood. For that reason, I suggested that we should consider taking official positions on these matters.

As it happens, just a couple of days later the Mayor and City Council President of Saint Paul circulated sample resolutions in opposition to the stadium sales tax to the mayors and councils of Ramsey County suburbs. A few days later, one of the county commissioners promoting the tax circulated another sample resolution in favor of the plan for stadium funding.

So last night we considered both resolutions. In advance of the meeting I had revised the Saint Paul-supplied resolution, to add a couple things I thought were important and to make it specific to Maplewood. My revised resolution passed unanimously.

The text of the resolution is as follows:

Resolution opposing the imposition of a ½ cent sales tax in Ramsey County for the construction of a Vikings Stadium in Arden Hills

WHEREAS, the Maplewood City Council recognizes the social and economic value of the Minnesota Vikings Football team to the State of Minnesota; and,

WHEREAS, to preserve the Minnesota Vikings as a valuable State amenity, the Maplewood City Council understands the desire to find a solution to the Vikings’ stated interest in developing a new stadium; and,

WHEREAS, a proposal has been put forth by the Minnesota Vikings and the Ramsey County Board of Commissioners to construct a new stadium in Arden Hills on the site of the former Twin Cities Army Ammunitions Plant (TCAAP); and,

WHEREAS, to finance the construction of this facility, the Ramsey County Board has proposed the imposition of a ½ cent sales tax collected in Ramsey County in an amount sufficient to generate $350 million; and,

WHEREAS, it has been proposed that the taxpayers of Ramsey County be denied the right to vote for or against a stadium-funding sales tax increase in a referendum; and,

WHEREAS, Maplewood retailers face competition from nearby counties that would have lower sales tax rates if this stadium tax were approved, as well as internet retailers who often do not collect sales taxes at all; and,

WHEREAS, a higher local sales tax rate may make Maplewood commercial properties less attractive than those in neighboring counties, potentially hurting property values in an already difficult real estate market and increasing the relative tax burden on residential properties; and,

WHEREAS, the City of Maplewood, even while losing all Market Value Homestead Credit payments from the State of Minnesota, has sought both to minimize the growth of taxes on our residents and to maintain the funding of basic municipal functions; and,

WHEREAS, it is unfair and inequitable for the residents and businesses of Maplewood to be asked to bear a disproportionate financial burden for the construction of a State-wide and region-wide amenity, particularly when the benefit to taxpayers is tangential at best;

NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Maplewood City Council opposes the imposition of a ½ cent sales tax in Ramsey County to support the construction of a Vikings stadium in Arden Hills; and,

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Maplewood City Council encourages the Governor, the Legislature, the Ramsey County Board, the Minnesota Vikings and other interested parties to consider options for constructing a stadium that minimize risk to the taxpayers, limit the level of public subsidy (particularly for the host community), and promote a fair, multi-jurisdictional participation for a State-wide amenity.

Labels:

Monday, April 25, 2011

Insurance Returning to Normal

One of the reasons I ran for the Maplewood City Council four years ago was the blinkered incompetence of the previous city council majority and the utterly unqualified crony that they installed as city manager, with whose assistance they turned city government into a vehicle for pursuing their own personal vendettas.  This cost taxpayers dearly, as a series of illegal firings racked up big legal expenses, out-of-court settlements, and court judgements.  Much of the actual dollars were paid by our insurer, the League of Minnesota Cities Insurance Trust -- which means that taxpayers all over the state picked up the tab for the old regime's malice and incompetence.

It was not without consequences for Maplewood, however.  We came close to losing our coverage, and our insurance policy was renewed only with special conditions setting a much higher deductible than usual.  Last year we saw our deductible lowered, in recognition of the city's return to responsible governance.  The latest good news on tonight's agenda is that this year we are looking at another improvement, which should return us to the state of insurance normalcy we enjoyed before our former mayor and her pals took over city hall.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, November 24, 2010

Improving Reputation

One of the goals set early this year by the City Council was to improve the reputation of Maplewood, and at this past Monday's meeting we discussed some of the city's progress toward that goal.  An article in today's Star Tribune looks at the subject as well.

Labels: ,

Thursday, August 12, 2010

Unaudited 2010 Special Election Results

Maplewood's City Clerk compiled an unaudited election results report for the special election, on a precinct-by-precinct basis, and e-mailed it to various folks including the candidates and the City Council. I've uploaded it for anyone curious.

Not suprisingly, given the different levels of attention people often pay to city versus higher level elections, more than 600 voters cast ballots but did not mark a choice in the city race.

For those who like to slice and dice the numbers, here's one spreadsheet I did for analysis -- looking at each candidate's percentage of the city council vote in each precinct. It's interesting to see where the candidates demonstrated strength or weakness, indicating where they have strong ties in the community or perhaps where they focused their campaigning.

Koppen's best precinct was 10 (58%), which I believe is his home precinct; it was also the worst for Sletten (10%). Even in his worst precinct (P13), Koppen still earned a respectable 46% of the vote.

One of Sletten's best precincts was P2, home to former mayor Diana Longrie (who was also on the ballot as a primary candidate, there to be mauled by Rep. McCollum), where she earned 24% of the ballots. In the seventh precinct, where she lives, Sletten only received her city-wide average of 19%. Perhaps familiarity has bred something there?

Two of Cave's three strongest precincts, all at around 34%, were Gladstone's P4, which was arguably the engine for her 2006 special election win (following up on all the neighborhood fears drummed in in the regular election the fall before), and her home Precinct 9. On the other hand, the 25% she got in Precinct 3 (where I live, as does Councilmember Juenemann) was her worst performance in the city.

Labels: ,

Saturday, March 06, 2010

Report from the 2010 Retreat

For anyone looking for some light weekend reading with lots of bullet points, I've uploaded the Executive Summary prepared by the facilitator following our February 5th council/staff retreat.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

The Queen in Exile

On that goofy Bob Zick cable show last week, Zick referred to Diana Longrie as "the real mayor" and stated that he does not recognize Mayor Rossbach as anything more than "chairperson." I suppose that's cute, but I'm getting reports that at least one person seems to take it seriously — the former mayor herself. I've been told that she has been seen at meetings sporting a name tag that identifies her as Mayor of Maplewood. And a resident recently complained about an announcement that played on cable TV:
There was a spot on Channel 15 public access tonight [Feb. 15th], Diana Longrie had an “ad” or a spot that was about 30 seconds, encouraging citizens to join her in asking the State Auditor to audit Maplewood’s financial records. Her name and “Maplewood Mayor” were flashed on the screen...
What in the world is going on? Does she have a delusion that she is still the mayor, never mind that democratic process that took place last November? Does she so crave the attention and deference that she enjoyed while bearing the title, she's unable to let it go? Or is this a political ploy to confuse the electorate or somehow sway them as part of her campaign for the council seat in the special election?

Labels: ,

Thursday, February 11, 2010

The Bob Zick Comedy Hour

North Saint Paul resident Bob Zick is a regular at our council meetings, always looking to create footage of himself to show on his cable access TV show. At this past Monday's meeting, he promised that he would be showing the video shot by his camera people (primarily the former mayor's husband) at last week's city council retreat and the citizens forum. Wondering what clips he would find to take wildly out of context, I TiVo'd his show out of curiosity and skimmed through it.

As it turns out, he never did play any video from either the retreat or the citizens forum. He played lot of video, but it all seemed to be him talking to the city council at our last two meetings. You'd think that fresh footage (not available online on demand) would be more interesting to his audience. Then again, the retreat was a nine-hour meeting that didn't include Bob Zick talking, so perhaps there wasn't any footage of interest to his regular viewer(s).

I did get a chance to see many examples of how spectacularly uninformed, misinformed and mathematically illiterate Mr. Zick is. For example, he went on about “pre-agenda meetings,” which have not been in place as long as I've been on the council. Those were meetings held the Thursday before a regular council meeting. The mayor and council would review the packet with staff, ask questions, and give staff a couple of days to research answers for the Monday meeting if they didn't have them already.

He also declared that this year's city council was working in secrecy out of the public eye, because we decide things in workshops, which are not broadcast. Umm...except that all our council workshops have been broadcast as long as I've been on the council. If you missed them, because they tend to start at some time between 4:30 and 5:30, all of the workshops since the start of 2010 are or will be archived for online viewing on demand.

Mr. Zick likes to pull amazing numbers out of the air, and declare them to be well-established facts. At one point he announced that the council/staff retreat cost $30,000-40,000; another time he said $80,000. I think I heard him say one point that city employees are paid $80 per hour (that would be $166,400 per year, though state law caps local government salaries at about $145,000), and he then multiplied that figure by the months of staff time he imagines went into setting up the retreat. At one point he claimed that meals at the retreat were “catered” and cost $10,000.



Sounds lavish, doesn't it! You might be imagining some high society party with sterling silver canape forks and servants in black ties.

Well, I never saw the caterers. It looked to me like city staff just set out snacks, drinks (coffee, hot water for tea, a cooler of soda pop), disposable cups and plates, and take-out food from some local restaurants. For breakfast there were a few things of yogurt, some muffins, coffee, two half gallon cartons of juice (pour your own into a paper cup), and some sliced fruit like you might pick up at Cub or Rainbow. At noon we had boxed lunches from Panera. For dinner, some big aluminum trays of salad and pasta, and some Italian bread (not heated like that fancy garlic bread you might have heard of, just cold sliced bread with packets of butter to spread on it yourself) from an Italian restaurant were set out for the five councilmembers and eleven staff members.

It says a lot about Mr. Zick's financial acuity that he imagines this spread would cost $10,000. Let's average $3,333 per meal – maybe less for breakfast (smaller, since department heads didn't join the retreat until lunchtime), more for dinner (what with bread on the side and some fancy packets of optional crushed red peppers for culinary thrill-seekers). I'm going to say there were no more than twenty boxed lunches from Panera (which, let's remember, is located in the same building that Mr. Zick claims as his Maplewood address). Do the math, $3,333 ÷ 20...

So the next time you see Mr. Zick claiming to speak with authority on any topic whatsoever, just remember — this is a guy who convinced himself that a six-inch sandwich, cookie and chips in a cardboard box from Panera Bread costs $167. I don't know about you, but I wouldn't trust him to buy lunch unsupervised, let alone advise my local government on policy and operations.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, February 09, 2010

My Notes from the 2/5/10 Council-Management Retreat

On Friday, February 5th, a long overdue City Council-Management Team retreat was held all day at the fire station on Clarence Street. The purpose of the retreat was threefold: to set council direction and goals for the next 2-3 years, identify short-term priorities, and build trust and better ways of working between staff and council. While we await a written report from the retreat facilitator, I thought I'd briefly write up my own notes from the day.

In the morning, the city council reviewed the city's assets and obstacles. Using a list of goals assembled from questionnaires the council had filled out prior to the meeting, we discussed and ranked those goals. The following emerged as our top seven:
  1. Re-establish Maplewood's Reputation — restore trust and respect between the citizens, staff, and elected officials, restore a positive image with our residents, the media and other government entitites

  2. Good Government — Make city government transparent and accessible, and operate with an environment of efficiency and mutual respect. Welcome and encourage citizen involvement, but not let the city's path be dictated simply by the loudest and most persistent voices that show up at city meetings.

  3. Parks Department — Reorganize, re-establish, revitalize; possible joint venture with neighboring communities

  4. (tie) Environmental Planning — Further develop processes for “going green”; enhance and fund open space management; includes follow-up on Fish Creek commission recommendations

  1. (tie) Fiscal Responsibility — Manage the city's finances and financial planning effectively, with an eye to providing stability and maximum value in the long term for our residents

  1. Complete the infrastructure upgrade process

  2. Redevelopment

In the afternoon, city department heads joined the retreat. Each councilmember and staff member in the retreat was asked to identify ten short-term objectives or priorities. The following items were on the list of majorities of both group (three or more councilmembers, plus six or more of the eleven management team staff):
  • Maintain Quality Services
  • Integration of Parks and Recreation; Parks Funding
  • Economic Development
  • Investment in Redevelopment
  • In-depth survey of citizens
  • Investment in infrastructure
With nine hours of work and discussion, there was a lot more to it than these two lists, but this provides at least some idea of the areas of consensus that emerged from the retreat. It was time well spent, and I look forward to working with my fellow councilmembers and the staff in going forward to achieve these goals and objectives.

Labels: , ,

Saturday, February 06, 2010

This Week's Review in Review

The Maplewood City Council gets a lot of ink in this week's Maplewood Review. You can read the articles online about Julie Wasiluk's temporary council appointment, the passing of the sign ordinance (minus two sections for further study and discussion), and the final passage of the amended recreational fire ordinance.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

The Smoke Clears

Remember all the controversy about wood smoke? Remember how, right before the election, a few pamphleteers and cable access TV shows purported to have uncovered a secret agenda on the part of mayoral candidate Will Rossbach to ban recreational fires, fireplaces, wood stoves, etc.?

Last night we passed the second reading of the amended recreational fire ordinance. It becomes law as soon as it's published in the official newspaper. Contrary to all the election-season bleatings of Maplewood's conspiracy mongers, we didn't ban wood fires. In fact, most members of the city council told you all along, if you asked, that no ban was ever being considered.

But from the outset of the wood smoke task force, some people (including certain now-former councilmembers) have worked hard to fan the flames of fear with rumors that a ban on wood burning was imminent. Denials could only be seen as proof of the sinister scheme underway, to their way of thinking.

Now that the ordinance has actually passed (and there is no ban, in case that was unclear), the naked dishonesty and cynicism of these conspiracy mongers should be plain to all.

What we actually did do:
  • Changed the ordinance to conform to state law (which supercedes our ordinances anyway) where they were in conflict. Examples: Our old ordinance permitted coal as fuel for recreational fires, which Minnesota law prohibits; our ordinance allowed fires 20 feet from a structure, while the state requires a minimum of 25.
  • Extended the permitted hours for recreational fires, formerly from 2 PM to 11 PM, now from 10 AM to 11 PM.
  • Added a "good neighbor" clause that states "Recreational fires should not be lit or maintained if the smoke therefrom unreasonably causes discomfort or a negative impact to neighboring properties."
  • Added a wind restriction to allow recreational fires only when the wind is less than 15 mph.
And after all that controversy and character bashing, after turning a minor ordinance update into a political football, how many of those "concerned" people actually showed up last night to comment on the final passage of the ordinance? Zero.

Labels: , ,

Sunday, January 17, 2010

The Latest Call for Duplicate Audits

The Sunday Pioneer Press includes an article about a petition seeking signatures to ask the State Auditor to examine Maplewood's books. Leading the petition drive is Elizabeth Sletten, one of former Mayor Diana Longrie's most devoted fans (you may also remember her as one of the candidates in last year's city council primary), and Longrie herself.

Long-time readers of my blog may recall that we've talked about this before. As my term began in 2008, I seriously considered whether we should ask the State Auditor to look at our books, after the mismanagement and incompetence of the Longrie-Copeland era. You can read my entry on the topic from April 7, 2008.

Then-Mayor Longrie wrote an April 8, 2008 opinion article in the Pioneer Press about her wish to see an audit; she ran the same text as her article in the May 2008 city newsletter. Longrie's laundry list of concerns focused not on Copeland's time at the city's helm — rather, she wanted an inquiry to focus on policy disagreements such as the amount of city debt, and bizarre personal obsessions like someone joking about naming a street after Will Rossbach. (Perhaps Longrie thinks "Comedy Police" is part of the state auditor's job description.)

In the new Pioneer Press article, Sletten claims to have obtained more than 400 signatures so far — roughly the same number as votes she received in last year's primary. To meet the required 20% of registered Maplewood voters, she'll need about 4,200. Even then, the scope of the audit is determined by the auditors, not the petitioners. To quote the State Auditor's website:

If a petition audit is certified by the county auditor, staff from the Office of the State Auditor would then meet with a committee of petitioners to review the petitioners' concerns. The audit staff then would review the concerns to determine the scope of the audit. The audit might not include all the concerns identified by the petitioners if the audit staff determined that the concerns were based on decisions within the discretion of the governing body.

I believe the State Auditor would duplicate the work already done by our independent auditors every year — which, let's be clear, has included a lot of clean-up of issues from the Longrie-Copeland era. But staff and auditors have repeatedly told us that there's no evidence of wrongdoing, just errors that we can reasonably believe came as a result of the loss of most of the accounting department, who were driven away by the toxic environment created in City Hall by Copeland and his masters. To emphasize the point once again, a state audit would not just duplicate our independent auditors' work, but the city's taxpayers would have to pay for the cost of the audit in a year when the budget is already stretched thin.

I don't believe that this money would be well spent, especially in these lean budgetary times. Still, if 20% of Maplewood voters want it, we'll indulge the personal obsessions of the former mayor and her cronies on the taxpayers' dime once again. I don't expect anything shocking will turn up, but I do still have my own list of questions, as I wrote in May 2008, that I will happily submit to the auditors if they're going to be examining the city's affairs anyhow.

Labels: , ,

Sunday, January 10, 2010

Pioneer Press Mourns Loss of Incivility

The Pioneer Press editorial writers had some fun last week at the expense of Maplewood and the anticipated decline of our previously thriving headline manufacturing sector. "But where are tomorrow's quips, headlines, conflicts, gaffes and attacks going to come from, if not from our elected leaders?" they write. " This agreeableness has got to stop."

Labels: ,

Older Posts

Posts by Date

Powered by Blogger & Blogger Templates. Customized by Michelle Nephew.
Contact me at
john@johnnephew.com